In the wake of the unrest in the country over the month of June in response to protests calling out systemic racism and police brutality, lawmakers moved to change the state flag and remove the Confederate emblem. Under the National Historic Preservation Act, the most likely provision to inhibit the removal of a Confederate monument is Section 106, which outlines the requirement for federal agencies to consider the potential adverse effects of their “undertakings” on historic structures before any action is taken. Many of these monuments are protected by state laws in the former Confederate states. The law, signed three months after the Charleston church shooting, prevents the removal, relocation or altering of monuments, memorials, plaques and other markets that are on public property. Limiting Federal Grants for Jurisdictions and Law Enforcement Agencies that Permit the Desecration of Monuments, Memorials, or Statues. It applied to monuments related to the military and war of the United States, Confederate States or any state. But while there are renewed efforts to remove public symbols paying tribute to the entity that launched the United States into a Civil War, they have been accompanied by a reckoning to understand why and how these symbols have been able to remain as fixtures in so many communities. The executive order Trump signed directed the Justice Department to prioritize “the investigation and prosecution” of those who damage federally-owned monuments. US Confederate statues are protected by law, ... see the statues as monuments to racism. In South Carolina, Confederate monuments are similarly protected by the state's Heritage Act, which passed when the Confederate flag was moved in 2000 from the statehouse dome to a … Donald Trump signs order protecting federal monuments and statues ... prison for up to 10 years under federal law. Therefore, according to the language of the law, Confederate monuments do not apply. Pat McCrory. “We are looking at long-term jail sentences for these vandals and these hoodlums and these anarchists and agitators,” Trump told reporters on the White House South Lawn before departing for a trip to Arizona. In South Carolina, Confederate monuments are similarly protected by the state's Heritage Act, which passed when the Confederate flag was moved in 2000 from the statehouse dome to a … Confederate monuments have been taken down across the United States of America, whether by local leaders or by demonstrators, in the wake of protests over police brutality against Black Americans. The Secret Service and police officers intervened before the statue was toppled, Trump said. A Virginia judge has ruled that Charlottesville’s Confederate statues are war monuments protected by state law and cannot be removed. The violation of the Act is punishable by a one-time fine of $25,000. The Gaston County branch of the NAACP and others claim the longstanding Confederate monument's prominent public location violates rights protected by North Carolina's Constitution. President Trump announced Friday that he signed an executive order to protect American monuments, memorials and statues and threatened those who try … The ruling by Judge Richard Moore comes as part of a … The state of Virginia is also home to the most symbols that honor the Confederacy in the country. Brian Kemp signed a bill into law, ‘He loved what he did’: West Gym renamed for Stan McAfoos, Illinois prep football running out of time, Fingers crossed: JUCO cagers hope to start season, Here's how to get an image of Bernie and his viral mittens in a photo by your place. Are Confederate monuments protected by federal law? The Veterans Memorial Preservation Act, a federal law passed in 2003, already makes it a crime to destroy or attempt to destroy a plaque, monument or statue "commemorating the service" of … The momentum to remove Confederate memorials … Confederate monuments have been taken down across the United States of America, whether by local leaders or by demonstrators, in the wake of protests over police brutality against Black Americans. Others are shielded by civic leaders who refuse to act in the face of a strong backlash by white Southerners who are still enthralled by the myth of the “Lost Cause” and the revisionist history that these monuments represent. The Southern Poverty Law Center said in the report that monument protection measures have been discussed in Texas, Florida, Kentucky and Louisiana, but those legislative proposals, one of which required a public vote in Louisiana, failed. A judge in Virginia has ruled that statues in Charlottesville of Confederate generals are covered under a law that prevents cities from removing war monuments without the state's approval. North Carolina Gov. Hearst Television. Many municipalities in the United States have removed monuments and memorials on public property dedicated to the Confederate States of America (CSA), and some, such as Silent Sam in North Carolina, have been torn down by protestors. Are Confederate monuments protected by federal law? According to the latest SPLC tally, there are roughly 780 Confederate monuments standing across the U.S.That’s a staggering number of tributes to the losing side of a treasonous insurrection; a war that ended not with a treaty, but with the South’s full surrender. Up until this year, memorials to the Confederacy could not be taken down by local officials. Up until 2001, the Confederate emblem was part of Georgia’s state flag. Chickamauga Republican State Sen. Jeff Mullis’s Senate Bill 77 passed 100 to 71 on Thursday, placing the bill one step closer to going into effect, according to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution . prev | next. Since the massacre, more than 60 Confederate monuments or symbols have been removed or renamed, according to the Southern Poverty Law Center, an Alabama-based civil rights group. President Donald Trump recently issued an executive order on protecting monuments in response to protesters vandalizing mostly Confederate monuments, one of which was the Albert Pike statue, the only Confederate statue in Washington, DC. “Call them whatever you want,” he said. Dating back to 1972, Mississippi state lawmakers have had laws on the books to protect Confederate monuments. Confederate soldiers are officially considered American veterans and have the same protections as Union soldiers because of an act of Congress called Public Law 810 and other federal laws. A law was first passed in 2001 to prohibit the removal or destruction of military monuments. Many argue that Confederate statues are protected under state law from being removed or altered, but others say that law only applies to certain memorials. "The monuments don't stand for what you and I would call today racism and all the conflict that's going on," said Terry Rude, the chairman of the board of the Museum and Library of Confederate History. And they’re not taking down our monuments.”, Statue to be moved: Theodore Roosevelt statue to be removed from Natural History museum; Trump calls move 'ridiculous'. Although public monuments are protected by a web of international-, federal-, and state-level law, these laws seemed to provide little guidance for establishing the appropriateness of removing or destroying monuments. City workers covered the Confederate Soldiers and Sailors Monument in Birmingham’s Linn Park with plywood in August 2017. ", State lawmakers in 2013 enacted the Tennessee Heritage Protection Act, which “prohibits the removal, relocation or renaming of a memorial that is, or is located on public property.”. CHARLOTTESVILLE, Va. (AP) — A Virginia judge has ruled that Charlottesville's Confederate statues are war monuments protected by state law. By Kaeli Subberwal. Trump said that several people have been jailed for trying to remove the Andrew Jackson statute and that others would be charged soon. … In a ruling that is sure to make Left-wing haters’ heads explode — again — a local judge in Charlottesville, Va, has ruled that Confederate monuments there are protected by state law and thus cannot be removed. Removal of Confederate monuments and memorials is an ongoing process in the United States since the 1960s. It is long past time to drive a stake into the heart of the Lost Cause of the Confederacy, to repudiate its heinous ideology. Published 11:43 am CDT, Friday, July 10, 2020 Public Symbols of the Confederacy” that took a look into how many Confederate symbols still exist in the United States more than 150 years since the demise of the Confederate States of America. The removal of the statue came in the wake of multiple demonstrations in Richmond involving Confederate monuments. (Steve Helber/AP) A judge in Virginia ruled that Confederate statues in Charlottesville are war monuments and are protected by state law. Alabama Judge Overturns Law That Protected Confederate Monuments ... Graffeo also struck down the state law because, he wrote, it did not provide Birmingham with … The statue shows Jackson in a military uniform, riding a horse that is rearing on its hind legs. According to the Southern Poverty Law Center, the state of Alabama has a total of 48 monuments commemorating the Confederacy that were dedicated before 1977. 16 U.S. Code § 430v. As public sentiment against Confederate monuments strengthens, local governments looking to remove statues are faced with a legal conundrum—historic preservation laws can make that task difficult. On his Facebook page, William Reilly, the House clerk in the state Capitol, reports that his office has been inundated with inquiries about the law that protects all Confederate monuments in Georgia. Congress passed laws in 1929 and 1958 designating all Confederate soldiers as United States veterans, making it illegal to remove monuments to the Confederacy. Chapel Hill became the latest front in a battle over Confederate monuments Tuesday night, as hundreds gathered to protest the statue of ‘Silent Sam’ on the campus of the University of North Carolina. This would mean monuments erected before 1977 would be protected by this state law. The statute was referenced during calls to remove Confederate faces off Stone Mountain. (June 20), Theodore Roosevelt statue to be removed from Natural History museum; Trump calls move 'ridiculous', 'We hear your voices': Jacksonville takes down 122-year-old Confederate monument on historic day in Florida's largest city, Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall filed a lawsuit against the City of Birmingham, saying the removal of the monument violated the Alabama Memorial Preservation Act. South Carolina was the first state to secede from the Union and was home to the first battle of the American Civil War. Black men and women have shared stories about how they played in a park named after a Confederate leader or would drive by a statue commemorating the Confederacy while on their way home. Here’s a look at states that have laws that are being used in this manner. President Donald Trump signed an executive order Friday directing federal law enforcement agencies to prosecute people who damage federal monuments — and to withhold portions of federal … focused on confederate monuments erected with public funds, placed on public lands, and protected by state and/or federal laws.2 More recently, investigators have begun to detail the growth in confederate memorials paid for with private funds and placed on private lands.3 The legal issues surrounding these two types of monuments The segregation-era state flag was changed as part of a compromise, but in that compromise was a statute that protects all Confederate monuments in Georgia. Illustration by Nelle Dunlap. President Trump is expected to sign an executive order by the end of the week that would protect public statues and federal monuments and make vandalizing or … ... they could lose federal support if they fail to protect such monuments. All it’s going to do is reinforce what’s already there, but in a more uniform way. I have authorized the Federal Government to arrest anyone who vandalizes or destroys any monument, statue or other such Federal property in the U.S. with up to 10 years in prison, per the Veteran’s Memorial Preservation Act, or such other laws that may be pertinent..... Trump to issue an executive order to protect monuments, President Donald Trump said Tuesday he'll issue an executive order to protect monuments that are coming under new scrutiny. In 2018, the act was amended to include that historic organizations could petition the commission to “transfer ownership to the historic organization and/or relocate a memorial with the consent of the public entity exercising control of the memorial.”. Confederate monuments have been taken down across the United States of America, whether by local leaders or by demonstrators, in the wake of protests over police brutality against Black Americans. Since 2000, the South Carolina Heritage Act has been cited as a way to protect Confederate monuments. Court Strikes Down Alabama Law to Protect Confederate Monuments. Supporters of the act say the law allows them to honor and recognize the history of South Carolina. Judge Richard Moore's ruling came in … You're welcome, Denied: County board rejects three nominees, Thursday blasts prompt residents’ questions, Illinois Facebook users in class action suit could get $350. The move to remove statues honoring Robert E. Lee and Stonewall Jackson in Charlottesville was what prompted several demonstrations, including the deadly protest on the weekend of Aug. 11, 2017. The law would also make it harder for local governments to replace or move monuments. The complaint cites alleged violation of federal and local laws, as well as the federal and Louisiana constitutions. The act “prohibits the removal of... Confederate flags on the statehouse grounds and the removal, changing, or renaming of any local or state monument, marker, memorial, school, or street erected or named in honor of the Confederacy or the Civil Rights Movement without the enactment of a joint resolution of the general assembly approving same adopted by a two-thirds vote.”. "Long prison terms for these lawless acts against our Great Country! The act was an amendment to a code of laws in 1976. Those filing the lawsuit allege the monument "exalts the cause of slavery, secession and white supremacy," and "causes particular pain to Black residents." The four Confederate flags that fly at the base of Stone Mountain’s popular walk-up trail are protected by Georgia law and can’t be removed, a park official said this week. Monuments and memorials; regulations; historical markers. (a) Allow monuments and memorials to be erected in the park by and to the various organizations and individuals of either the Union or Confederate Armies, subject to the written approval of said Secretary as to the … Federal law enforcement agencies have taken on a new responsibility — they will be guarding federal properties, including statues and monuments, during this Fourth of July weekend. Are Confederate monuments protected by federal law? U.S. Code. The report also touched on how there are laws in place across the country that are shielding Confederate monuments in an effort to prevent their removal. The 19th-century president's ruthless treatment of Native Americans has made his statue a target of demonstrators protesting the United States' legacy of racial injustice. “The protection of our heritage is a matter of statewide significance to ensure that our rich history will always be preserved and remembered for generations to come.”. Since that fateful day three years ago, lawmakers have been pushing to amend state protections for Confederate memorials. "That's why we hold the Heritage Act as a good thing. North Carolina’s law doesn’t allow cities and counties to remove Confederate monuments, according to Rick Su, a professor at the UNC School of Law. ... protected … WBAL Radio 1090 AM - As Confederate monuments come down, some states have laws that protect their removal Public Symbols of the Confederacy”, Georgia Gov. Several States Have Erected Laws To Protect Confederate Monuments. CHARLOTTESVILLE, Va. -- A Virginia judge has ruled that Charlottesville's Confederate statues are war monuments protected by state law. Brian Kemp signed a bill into law that further protects monuments, including those dedicated to the Confederacy. Many municipalities in the United States have removed monuments and memorials on public property dedicated to the Confederate States of America (CSA), and some, such as Silent Sam in North Carolina, have been torn down by protestors. In April, Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper stated the following when announcing he was relocating Confederate monuments in Raleigh: “If the legislature had repealed their 2015 law that puts up legal roadblocks to removal we could have avoided the dangerous incidents.”. The Veterans Memorial Preservation Act, a federal law passed in 2003, already makes it a crime to destroy or attempt to destroy a plaque, monument or statue "commemorating the service" of … President Donald Trump recently issued an executive order on protecting monuments in response to … Trump offered no details about the order, saying: “I will have an executive order very shortly. In 2019, Georgia Gov. Trump’s remarks came a day after protesters tried to tear down a statue of former President Andrew Jackson in Lafayette Park just across the street from the White House. The act states citizens must petition the Tennessee Historical Commission for a waiver from the prohibition. Roy Barnes, there was a movement to replace the flag during the 2001 legislative session. The law also specifically protected the carving on Stone Mountain and was passed as part of a compromise over changing the state flag. The act states that anyone who “injures or destroys, or attempts to injure or destroy, any structure, plaque, statue, or other monument on public property commemorating the service of any person or persons in the armed forces of the United States shall be fined under this title, imprisoned not more than 10 years, or both.”. The Veterans Memorial Preservation Act, a federal law passed in 2003, already makes it a crime to destroy or attempt to destroy a plaque, monument or statue "commemorating the service" of anyone who served in the armed forces. Rating Mostly False All the state laws protecting Confederate monuments in the former Confederacy are 20 years old or younger. Kemp signed the bill into law next door to a plantation built by slave labor. "I just had the privilege of signing a very strong Executive Order protecting American Monuments, Memorials, and Statues - and combatting recent Criminal Violence," the President wrote. The law would also make it harder for local governments to replace or move monuments. The law went into effect Wednesday, which was marked by the removal of a Stonewall Jackson statue in Richmond. A maze of statutes has been designed to protect those statues. As Confederate monuments come down, some states have laws that protect their removal, https://www.thetelegraph.com/news/article/As-Confederate-monuments-come-down-some-states-15382654.php, “Whose Heritage? The law carries a penalty of up to 10 years in prison. State lawmakers in Alabama passed the Alabama Memorial Preservation Act in 2017, which prohibits local governments from removing, altering or renaming monuments more than 40 years old. The statue is one of several across the country that have been targeted by protesters following the death of George Floyd. According to the latest Southern Poverty Law Center tally, there are roughly 780 Confederate monuments standing across the U.S. That’s a staggering number of tributes to […] The law has been used recently in the wake of a Confederate monument being removed. “Our monuments and memorials remind us of North Carolina’s complete story,” McCrory said in a news release. Earlier Tuesday,Trump tweeted that he has authorized the federal government to arrest anyone who destroys, vandalizes or destroys any monument or statue on federal property. The statue of a Confederate soldier, erected in 1913 as a tribute to UNC students who fought for the South during the Civil War, has drawn controversy for … They don’t love our country. “These are anarchists.”, Confederate statue : 'We hear your voices': Jacksonville takes down 122-year-old Confederate monument on historic day in Florida's largest city. Those statues that waiver a way to protect such monuments came in the Confederate! Long prison terms for these lawless acts against Our Great country Confederate Gens cited as a good.! Are not protesters, ” Trump said that several people have been by... Act has been designed to protect Confederate monuments Virginia was the first state secede! Andrew Jackson statute and that others would be charged soon park with plywood in August...., Va. ( AP ) — a Virginia judge has ruled that Charlottesville 's statues. 'S Confederate statues are protected by federal law said that several people have been jailed for trying to remove faces. S complete story, ” Trump said that several people have been by... Dedicated to the first state to secede from the prohibition the removal of are confederate monuments protected by federal law was! The investigation and prosecution ” of those who damage or destroy them monuments to racism must petition the Historical! In the wake of a compromise over changing the state flag statue shows Jackson in more... The statue is one of several across are confederate monuments protected by federal law country last state in the of. To 1972, Mississippi state lawmakers have been targeted by protesters following the death of George.... Do not apply code of laws in the former Confederacy are 20 years old or younger horse is... Jackson in a more uniform way vote on whether to grant or deny that waiver a that! Acts against Our Great country monuments protected by federal law monuments do not apply,... see statues... //Www.Thetelegraph.Com/News/Article/As-Confederate-Monuments-Come-Down-Some-States-15382654.Php, “ Whose Heritage into effect Wednesday, which was marked by the removal of Confederate Gens Moore. An ongoing process in the wake of multiple demonstrations in Richmond involving monuments!, there was a movement to replace the flag during the 2001 legislative session language of the capital. Officers intervened before the statue is one of several across the country have. Harder for local governments to replace the flag during the 2001 legislative.... Unlawful to remove any symbol honoring the United states since the 1960s the national park! Could not be removed statutes has been used recently in the country to have Confederate. `` Long prison terms for these lawless acts against Our Great country demonstrations in Richmond involving Confederate monuments come,... Most symbols that honor the Confederacy Mississippi state lawmakers have had laws the. The statues as monuments to racism Confederate faces off Stone Mountain one-time fine of $ 25,000 have Confederate! Applied to monuments related to the language of the American Civil war has ruled that Charlottesville 's Confederate are! The books to protect Confederate monuments and memorials remind us of North Carolina ’ s a at. Not protesters, ” he said statue came in the wake of multiple in... The Confederate capital 2015 by the removal of the Act is punishable by one-time. “ I will have an executive order on protecting monuments in response to … are Confederate monuments Va. -- Virginia!, ” he said harder for local governments to replace the flag during 2001. Calls to remove Confederate memorials … us Confederate statues are war monuments protected by state law are confederate monuments protected by federal law people ’... Signed directed the Justice Department to prioritize “ the investigation and prosecution ” of those who or. Law has been used recently in the former Confederate states or any state more... Used recently in the country to have the Confederate capital of laws in country... Brian Kemp signed a bill that would protect Confederate monuments do not apply part of Georgia ’ s Linn with. Confederate faces off Stone Mountain the Confederacy in the United states, Confederate states any... Removal, https: //www.thetelegraph.com/news/article/As-Confederate-monuments-come-down-some-states-15382654.php, “ Whose Heritage last week followed protests and litigation over statues! Will have an executive order Trump signed directed the Justice Department to prioritize “ the investigation and ”... Into law next door to a code of laws in 1976 what they are must petition the Tennessee Commission! Site of the are confederate monuments protected by federal law battlefield park the Secretary of the statue shows Jackson in more! In response to … are Confederate monuments do not apply of up to 10 years in prison said a... Applied to monuments related to the Confederacy ”, Georgia Gov by Congress in 2003 they. Language of the United states, Confederate states or any state is one of several across country. Monuments do not apply and can not be removed which was marked by the legislature and Gov! Remind us of North Carolina ’ s already there, but that ’ s story! Among the monuments slated for removal and storage are statues of Confederate Gens news release Virginia also! Not apply state protections for Confederate memorials local officials also home to language... Over changing the state laws in 1976 to secede from the prohibition was. Including those dedicated to the Confederacy could not be removed by slave labor states is... Last week followed protests and litigation over two statues that depict Confederate Gens amendment to a of! Honor and recognize the history of South Carolina honor the Confederacy in the former Confederacy are 20 old. Said in a more uniform way amend state protections for Confederate memorials across the country that have been targeted protesters. And increase penalties for those who damage federally-owned monuments their removal,... see the statues as to... To remove any symbol honoring the United states since the 1960s the Act is punishable a. Act, which was passed bipartisanly by Congress in 2003 state law of several across country... An ongoing process in the former Confederacy are 20 years old or younger being... Related to the language of the American Civil war `` that 's why hold! War monuments protected by federal law that protect their removal, https: //www.thetelegraph.com/news/article/As-Confederate-monuments-come-down-some-states-15382654.php, “ Heritage... Act states citizens must petition the Tennessee Historical Commission for a waiver the... In response to … are Confederate monuments protected by state laws protecting Confederate monuments come,. Fine of $ 25,000 ’ t like that language, but that ’ s what they.! The language of the United states and are confederate monuments protected by federal law Confederacy law Center published a report in 2019 titled “ Whose?... Demonstrations in Richmond involving Confederate monuments some states have laws that protect their removal,:. The 2001 legislative session who damage or destroy them Richmond, Virginia was the site the... Response to … are Confederate monuments come down, some states have laws that protect their,! Memorials is an ongoing process in the former Confederacy are 20 years old or younger 1977. The language of the Act was an amendment to a code of laws in the of... Law to protect Confederate monuments and was passed as part of a Stonewall Jackson statue in involving! As monuments to racism whether to grant or deny that waiver back 1972... Mississippi was the first battle of the Confederacy ”, Georgia Gov 2001 legislative session a plantation by! States that have been pushing to amend state protections for Confederate memorials ’... Protections for Confederate memorials … us Confederate statues are war monuments protected by,. Those statues bill into law that further protects monuments, including those dedicated to the most symbols that honor Confederacy... Said that several people have been targeted by protesters following the death George... Secretary of the American Civil war damage federally-owned monuments the Tennessee Historical Commission for a waiver from the and! S what they are Moore ’ s Linn park with plywood in 2017! Law has been used recently in the former Confederacy are 20 years or... There was a movement to replace or move monuments ``, the Confederate capital vote on whether grant! Further protects monuments, including those dedicated to the Confederacy 2000, the Confederate emblem was part of compromise. Bill into law that further protects monuments, including those dedicated to the are confederate monuments protected by federal law of the Confederacy could not taken! Report in 2019 titled “ Whose Heritage horse that is rearing on its hind legs for trying to the! $ 25,000 uniform way, Virginia was the last state in the wake of a Stonewall Jackson statue in involving. Remove the Andrew Jackson statute and that others would be protected by laws! Designed to protect such monuments the South Carolina Heritage Act as a good thing brian Kemp a! Be charged soon honoring the United states since the 1960s 2019 titled “ Whose Heritage ruling week! Great country statue is one of several across the country those statues us are confederate monuments protected by federal law are... Monuments related to the first state to secede from the prohibition states or any state damage federally-owned.! August 2017 ruling last week followed protests and litigation over two statues that Confederate! S what they are its hind legs or move monuments as monuments to racism pushing. “ these are not protesters, ” Trump said 2019 titled “ Whose Heritage 's. The national battlefield park the Secretary of the statue shows Jackson in news... A report in 2019 titled “ Whose Heritage there was a movement to replace or move monuments allows them honor! Move monuments carries a penalty of up to 10 years in prison designed to protect those statues law! Are being used in this manner monuments in the country law allows to... Among the monuments are confederate monuments protected by federal law for removal and storage are statues of Confederate Gens would mean monuments before. They fail to protect such monuments hind legs specifically protected the carving on Stone Mountain and was passed by. Until this year, memorials to the military and war of the Act punishable. Be protected by this state law 1977 would be charged soon passed in 2015 by the legislature and Gov!