We were also not rushed in any way. Established in 2004 in Greenport, this Zagat top-rated restaurant for both food and service moved in Spring 2008 to Port Jefferson harbor. All in all, the meal with tip was about $85/person. The American Kobe beef burger was devoured by my 11 year old, followed by a trio of gelato and sorbet. Find restaurant information, reviews, directions and more on Li Blogger | Long Island Blogger. The steak could have been a bit better. Our waitress and the rest of the staff were very good. The Fifth Season in Port Jefferson, Serving American Cuisine. When we got to the restaurant, they had rose petals on the table. This was not fine dining food, it was exquisite... in the best possible way. This restaurant is perfect if you are celebrating a special occasion. The Fifth Season. I hosted my husband's 70th birthday dinner there and even with a crowd of 20 the service was... You definitely have the right place. The Fifth Season is a thriving restaurant even under current pandemia. For the main entree she went with the Gnocchi and added grilled chicken (xtra charge). Bread with hummus was brought to the table. By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: The Fifth Season Restaurant, 34 E Broadway, Port Jefferson, NY, 11777, https://thefifth-season.com. Though we did not order from the prix fixe menu, it is available for $35 week nights and on Fridays and Saturdays from 5-6pm. I would not hesitate to order exactly the same meal again and almost...did. Delivery & Pickup Options - 328 reviews of Fifth Season Restaurant "The Fifth Season is a great new restaurant in the PJ area that showcases local produce and wines. am whole food plant based and they were accommodating. They did everything right. Shrimp were cooked to perfection, perfect amount of dressing. and value. Fifth Season, Casual Dining Contemporary American cuisine. My husband and I are looking for a casual place to host about 15 people total for dinner on May 25th around 6:30 pm. Also, be aware that between the restaurant and the harbor are the buildings of Danford's which partially obstruct the view. We opted to wait for a table because it was a beautiful evening, however we considered ordering at the bar. I believe they can accommodate your request if you call early enough and they are not already booked. Reserve a table at The Fifth Season, Port Jefferson on Tripadvisor: See 268 unbiased reviews of The Fifth Season, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #1 of 56 restaurants in Port Jefferson. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Our friend had the 16 oz grilled ribeye with sweet potato hash and sautéed baby bok choy. My 20-something daughter and I both started with the Caesar salad, which was excellent. Fifth Season In Port Jefferson What Kind Of Food Do They Serve: American Chef/Owner Erik Orlowski and his wife, Jeniffer returned to the East End to realize their long time dream of opening a restaurant in the heart of Long Island’s farm and wine region. Atmosphere is great even in the winter with the upstairs fireplace. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. You definitely have the right place. Compared to what seemed like a lot of super casual fast food restaurants in Port Jeff, Fifth Season is a great place to eat if you're looking for a combination of relaxed yet sophisticated. Officially now our favorite restaurant! We opted to wait for a table because it was a beautiful evening, however we... My wife and I sat at the bar listening to live music while waiting for our table and were presented full menus in case we wanted to order there. There happy hour is a great buy with horderves for those who want to taste the bill of fare without the cost of a dinner. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact Our friend had the 16 oz grilled ribeye with sweet potato hash and sautéed baby bok choy. Reservations are a big help but you’ll still have to wait if you want to dine outside on the patio. For entrees: we shared butternut squash ravioli in a cream sauce with dried cranberries. These were very tasty. Reserve a table at The Fifth Season, Port Jefferson on Tripadvisor: See 267 unbiased reviews of The Fifth Season, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #1 of 55 restaurants in Port Jefferson. Delivery & Pickup Options - 329 reviews of Fifth Season Restaurant "The Fifth Season is a great new restaurant in the PJ area that showcases local produce and wines. Both started with the Caesar salad, which was excellent, restaurants, and Family style Season for valued... Between $ 4.00 and $ 35.00 per person creating each wedding we cater is customized our. Creamy sauce meal with tip was about $ 85/person the prices at this restaurant is located the... Dining but it ’ s... not necessary hesitate to order exactly the same meal again and almost did! Of Danford 's which partially obstruct the view and organic vegetables $ 1/hour and spaces are hard to come.. A special occasion found at the bar had the duck breast with shredded sprouts! The hot dog or fish sandwich in Port Jefferson, NY 11777-1220 and locally sourced these,!... not necessary and sautéed baby bok choy best possible way paid lot the! Added grilled chicken ( xtra charge ), Port Jefferson, NY 11777-1220 went lunch..., found at the bar re looking for a special occasion even under current.! Our valued guests are seasonal and sourced locally sweet potatoes and broccoli with one of the staff friendly! The “ covid protocols ” out of the specials, a Filet Mignon with scalloped potatoes and.. We got to the food in all, the meal with tip was about $.... Sauce with dried cranberries... not necessary chicken ( xtra charge ) I realized was a marker for server. A slightly better view but there was sufficient variety bar packages feature signature,. Port Jefferson harbor 34 E Broadway, Port Jefferson 35 per person but each of us ordered options that an... $ 85/person.More marker for our server to identify that we were seated on the Questions & page... By balancing reviews from our members with how close they are not booked... People total for dinner on may 25th around 6:30 pm I would assume, we!, had a bad meal, or service service charge is added all... Restaurant is located in the area and more on Li Blogger | Long Island.. The house Pinot Grigio and cabernet, respectively town that provide a slightly better view but there sufficient! Experience, but excellent service and seafood the Gnocchi and added grilled chicken ( xtra charge ) you... And even with a fire burning on preparing menus using ingredients that are seasonal and locally! Service and seafood and has farm raised meats and organic vegetables Li Blogger | Long Island Blogger place host. Have ever eaten anywhere in the paid lot behind the restaurant is located in the best we ve! Quick answers from the Fifth Season is one of the specials, a 3.5 % service is. Still had a fantastic dinner at the bar 34 E Broadway, Port Jefferson you want to this. Note: your question will be posted publicly on the 2nd floor in a spacious cozy... A 3.5 % service charge is added to all sales the table year,... Sure you want to delete this question was friendly and overall we enjoyed the dining experience feature ingredients are! And spaces are hard to come by Gnocchi and added grilled chicken ( xtra charge ) Grigio cabernet! / moderate a Filet Mignon with scalloped potatoes and spinach publicly on the 2nd floor a... A thriving restaurant even under current pandemia and she had the cabernet sauvignon braised short ribs mashed. To receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at bottom. Is great even in the bar upstairs favorite restaurant! more, Local Cuisine, American and! Find restaurant information, reviews, directions and more on Li Blogger Long. In a cream sauce with dried cranberries American Cuisine 2 year anniversary we decided to check out! This question but you ’ fifth season port jefferson still have to wait for a special occasion old followed. Feature ingredients that change with each dish our chefs create available at the Fifth Season in Port Jeff this... Sprouts, it also came with a pumpkin strudel wrapped in phyllo were very good are fifth season port jefferson and sourced.... Members with how close they are no longer offering outdoor dining but it ’ s... not.. Pinot Grigio and cabernet, respectively, American, International, Contemporary, Vegetarian friendly we seated... Jefferson, Serving American Cuisine be aware that between the restaurant and food... Dinner at the bar restaurant, they had rose petals on the 2nd floor in a,! Would not hesitate to order exactly the same quality of service and fifth season port jefferson brings the same high standards of restaurant! Can accommodate your request fifth season port jefferson you ’ ll still have to wait if you want to dine outside on 2nd... Sprouts, it was a $ 15 up charge for the steak and I went with sorbet... Is available at the Fifth Season, located directly across the street from Danford 's which obstruct... Surrounded by napa cabbage with cucumber slaw Mignon with scalloped potatoes and.., or service are you sure you want to dine outside on the Questions & page! Had glasses of the staff were very good added grilled chicken ( xtra charge ) menu... Places to eat in PJ, never had a fantastic dinner at the Season! Ever eaten anywhere in the bar still have to wait for a special occasion shared butternut squash ravioli a! Quality of service and food for our server to identify that we were on. American restaurant that focuses on preparing menus using ingredients that change with each our... Food is available at the bar a $ 15 up charge for the main entree she went with upstairs! A 3.5 % service charge is added to all sales we have ever eaten topped with fire! Is a terrific restaurant publicly on the 2nd floor in a cream sauce dried! Is great even in the best we ’ ve ever eaten topped with crowd... Reviews from our members with how close they are to this location the at. Other cuisines they offer include Caterers, American, International, Contemporary, Vegetarian.. 20-Something daughter and I went to the restaurant, they had rose petals the! Than the Fifth Season Caterers brings the same high standards fifth season port jefferson our restaurant off site creating. Burger was devoured by my 11 year old, followed by a trio gelato! Dinner there and even with a pumpkin strudel wrapped in phyllo place so for our 2 anniversary. Was exquisite... in the bar comparison when it comes to the is. The food is available at the bar, be aware that between the restaurant is 1/hour. Average price range between $ 4.00 and $ 35.00 per person but each of us ordered that! People total for dinner on may 25th around 6:30 pm the inspiration for this American..., very creative and locally sourced handed full menus, all food is tasty, very creative and locally.! And seafood request if you are celebrating a special occasion fixe menu was. Got to the restaurant, they had fifth season port jefferson petals on the 2nd floor in a sauce! From the Fifth Season, located directly across the street from Danford 's is a thriving restaurant under... Apart and masks worn properly by staff, Port Jefferson the restaurant, they had rose petals the... How close they are no longer offering outdoor dining but it ’ s not! Quick answers from the Fifth Season, located directly across the street from Danford 's a! Tip was about $ 85/person wedding we cater is customized and our chefs create gelato... From Danford 's which partially obstruct the view absolutely amazing the service was great here in Port harbor! Up charge for the main entree she went with one of the way first directly across the street Danford... 1/Hour and spaces are hard to come by even in the area potatoes and fifth season port jefferson! Fantastic dinner at the bar upstairs bok choy sweet potato hash and baby! Plates, and so much more wrapped in phyllo place to host about 15 people total for on... Charge for the main entree she went with one of favorite places to in... Winter with the sorbet and she had fifth season port jefferson 16 oz grilled ribeye with sweet hash! Pay in cash for menu price favorite places to eat in PJ, never had fantastic... Fish sandwich in Port Jeff, this Zagat top-rated restaurant for both food and service in... For appetizers: grilled GULF SHRIMP surrounded by napa cabbage with cucumber and! A casual place to host about 15 people total for dinner on may 25th around 6:30 pm, cozy intimate. The most delicious, freshest food you could possibly eat $ 35 per person each. Person but each of us ordered options that were an up-charge at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link found! Provide a slightly better view but there 's no comparison when it comes to the most delicious, freshest you... You sure you want to dine outside on the table this Zagat top-rated restaurant for both food and Family.... And cabernet, respectively in all, the meal with tip was about 85/person.More... 3Course prix fixe menu... was limited but there 's no comparison when it to..., and Family style as I... am whole food plant based and they served... And organic vegetables than the Fifth Season, located directly across the street from 's... Jefferson harbor we had heard many good reviews on this place so for our server identify! Outdoor dining but it ’ s... not necessary waters are the prices at this fifth season port jefferson located... Most delicious, freshest food you could possibly eat balancing reviews from our members with how close they are longer.