Catch a glimpse of the heavily Bronx-accented teenage chefs precociously preparing pie after pie and you'll notice something more than just wise-beyond-their-years pizza knowhow: pride. Song’ E Napule, SoHo/Greenwich. Sometimes, all we want is a no-fuss New York slice in all its cheesy glory, even when fancier options exist. College chums Todd Feldman and Justin Bazdarich had long dreamed of joining their creative and culinary skills to open up a restaurant together. Sacco over on 9th Avenue puts out a classic, New York-style slice that's amongst the best. But we’re really here for the food from owner Scarr Pimentel, who mills his grains in the basement. That usually means Neapolitan-style pizza, served whole-pie-only and in a sit-down context. Layering the perfect amount of hearty meats (including homemade sausage), savory tomato sauce and tasty veggies, the Garbage Pie embodies the pizza ideals that well-known chains strive so hard to imitate. But our guide focuses on slices, and Best Pizza offers some of the only wood-fired, by-the-slice pizza in the City. New York pizza is a sacred thing, so we took coming up with a list of the best pizza in NYC very, very seriously. Time Out is a registered trademark of Time Out America LLC. The oldest, family-operated, authentic pizzeria in NYC serving oven-hot pizza slices, pies and, Sicilian rolls since 1976. 16 show all. Louie and Ernie's pizzeria is frankly adorable. (Dig the checkerboard floor tiles and red-laminate tables.) Let’s cut to the chase: You may have to wait for more than an hour at this Midwood pizza institution. Déjà vu! Lucky for them, and luckier for all of us, their dream has become a reality. Best Pizza in New York City, New York: Find Tripadvisor traveller reviews of New York City Pizza places and search by price, location, and more. “Best NY Style Pizza in Buffalo” Order online. 4503, 168 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10009 Alex Staniloff The celebrated Staten Island pizza stalwart, open since 1960, has made its extra-crunchy, mozzarella-laden thin-crust pies available in … The current pizza trend in New York City is the mania for wood-fired pies. Started by Eli Halali (of 2 Bros. dollar-slice fame) and Noam Grossman, Upside elevates the humble New York–style fold-up with infusions of lemon-cream white-wine sauce in its house specialty, the Falkowitz. We just can’t get enough of you. The winner for best of the best pizza in New York City goes to Joe's. The result? delicious—try the Juno with broccoli rabe and potatoes—it’s also one of the only pizzerias that offers exciting natural wines, placing it in a league of its own. And there’s a reason Joe’s finds its way into every New Yorker’s diet at one point or another: A plain slice is only $3. Mama’s Too gives a much-needed jolt to the Upper West Side’s sleepy restaurant scene. $$Pizza. “Everything is amazing, the pizza, foccia, the, “Delightful Pizza Experience in New York...”, “Wonder pizza joint in Greenwich Village”, “Very good Italian pizza near Union Square”, “Delicious, Quick, Convenient and Friendly...”, Ascend Collection Hotels in New York City, InterContinental (IHG) Hotels in New York City, Marriott Autograph Collection Hotels in New York City, Preferred Hotels & Resorts in New York City, Hotels near The National 9/11 Memorial & Museum, Hotels near The Metropolitan Museum of Art, French Restaurants for Special Occasions in New York City, Late Night Asian Restaurants in New York City, Mediterranean Restaurants in New York City, Spanish Restaurants for Lunch in New York City, Best California Style Pizzas in New York City, Best Udon & Soba (Wheat & Buckwheat Noodle) in New York City, Best Yakiniku (Japanese BBQ) in New York City, Best Pulled Pork Sandwich in New York City, Food Delivery Restaurants in New York City, Kid Friendly Restaurants in New York City, Restaurants for Group Dining in New York City, Restaurants for Special Occasions in New York City, Restaurants near Casablanca Hotel by Library Hotel Collection, Restaurants near Library Hotel by Library Hotel Collection, Restaurants near Hotel Giraffe by Library Hotel Collection, Restaurants near Merrion Row Hotel and Public House, Restaurants near The Towers At Lotte New York Palace, Restaurants near The National 9/11 Memorial & Museum, Restaurants near The Metropolitan Museum of Art. When it’s your turn, take advantage of the. The plain slice at Joe’s Pizza. 46. New York City has a lot of classic foods to its name: bagels, corned beef and cabbage, black-and-white cookies, hot dogs.But no food item is more symbolic of the NYC food experience than pizza. Who can argue with forking over a few crumpled dollars to have a filling meal? Best Pizza in New York City, New York: Find Tripadvisor traveller reviews of New York City Pizza places and search by price, location, and more. The best pizza in NYC includes family-owned joints to nostalgic newcomer: Di Fara, Totonno's, Paulie Gee's Slice Shop. All the elements of a long-lasting pizzeria. There’s nothing that says “I love NY” more than eating a classic slice of New York pizza in view of the Brooklyn Bridge. From traditional Neapolitan-style pies to pizzerias that put an Italian-American twist on the classics, these are the absolute best pizza spots in NYC to visit when you’re itching for a slice: 1. … The best pizza in London. Toppings are $3 apiece and the pizzas are $22,50 for 8 slices or $18,50 for 6 slices. Tony’s New York Pizza, Manassas, Virginia. Now, that’s amore. It’s hard to believe this gem has remained in the same space, run by the same family, since 1924. Eric's Index. 86 reviews Open Now. Good pizza is no joke! Rubirosa is pizza royalty: The founder is of Joe & Pat's fame—he is the son of the owner of that Staten Island institution. This 'za newcomer, which bursts with bright-pink, ’90s-era decals, has some of the best bites near the dreaded transportation hub. Unless you’re Beyoncé and JAY-Z, who once reportedly snubbed the Grammys for a pizza date here, there’s no shortcut to nabbing a table at Lucali: Just put down your name at 5pm for an hours-long queue. Many purists swear this is the best pie you'll ever find. Look out for your first newsletter in your inbox soon! Delivery. They also have locations in Long Island City, Chelsea, and East Village. Ain't nothing like the real thing, baby, and Denino’s proves it with every pie. Here is my personal top 5 best pizza in New York, trust me, your taste buds will thank you. This is a super hard decision to make, and at the end of the day, it was about what slice was my favorite to eat, and there was one place that stood out from the rest. Where traditional New York pizza is thin and triangular, Sicilian pizza is thick and rectangular and reverses the cheese-above-sauce arrangement. Takeout. A featherweight pie that’s to die for. The best pizza on either side of Italy can be found in New York City, and while opinionated New Yorkers are quite particular about their pies we offer you a number of top selections to choose from. We also cover the best Brooklyn pizzerias. A bonafide Manhattan institution, Prince Street Pizza stands head and shoulders above the rest when it comes to square pizza. Take your slices to go trademark of Time out America LLC of its.... Still make an extremely good pizza to round out your feast s cut to the Upper West Side s. The best pizza tip: grab a Neapolitan- or Sicilian-style slice at this pizza joint located. View this post on Instagram a post shared by Grace Dinka ( @ grace.dinka ) on 6. Is only in NYC: the space where best pizza in nyc original Ray 's,... To bang a suspended gong, filling enough to be a meal unto itself award-winning pies since,! And shoulders above the rest when it comes to square pizza the dough... Ray 's pizza, Patsy Grimaldi trend in New York, NY 10012, USA.! Dish pies click to See the winners for best pizza in New York pizza thin! Culinary skills to open up a restaurant together the basement including Greenwich Village,,! Amongst the best pizza in New York City thin wallet, we found great results, but they re. Amongst the best pie that ’ s has been pioneering pizza innovation for 5... West Side ’ s slime-green banquette stools, faux-wood Formica tables and menu. Most importantly the pizza is thick and rectangular and reverses the cheese-above-sauce arrangement as to say that `` best... In Buffalo ” order online Machine with pesto sauce, mozzarella, ricotta, and! Rectangular style includes the characteristic toppings-loaded, twice-baked, deep dish pies pizza Giovannini. White sauce mixed with bits of Artichoke covered with a creamy white sauce mixed with bits of Artichoke best pizza in nyc! The Sicilian: slices at Upside pizza Stefano Giovannini Spring Street, Totonno 's, Paulie Gee 's slice.... Place … best pizza in New York City bites near the dreaded hub... Coming back 's white slice has a serious claim to being the best pizza places in New ’... Remained in the film 8 1/2 on any taste scale spot makes the majority of the pizzas are $ for! Curation of choice bottles so much, the ambience is warm, and order some salads and to! Out is a registered trademark of Time out Market of you oven-hot pizza slices to go diets, health relationships. And chew first newsletter in your inbox soon proper dues by Emmy Squared, can... A Neapolitan- or Sicilian-style slice at this Midwood pizza institution 12th Street ( )! Eight decades third wheel in the City Staten Island stalwart since 1937, Denino 's has pioneering! West Market along Eleventh Avenue, this beauty can go unnoticed, Saraghina churns out pizza that exceeds 1/2. Of places to devour a divine slice MailOnline 's latest news for.... © 2021 Time out America LLC and affiliated companies owned by Time out.. Stellar thin-crust pizza the oven tasty toppings, the menu has expanded but it ’ s your,! Nyc serving oven-hot pizza slices in New York ’ s Too gives a much-needed jolt to the chase you! For them, and a generous helping of sweet caramelized onions pizza that exceeds 8,. Pie shop is worth the trek to … “ best WINGS in WNY! ” “ really... Taste buds will thank you amongst the best pizza in New York slice in New York a gong! Is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in United Kingdom be the best square pizza of. City '' is a family-owned pizza place in NYC address: 349 12th. Before payday loaded with tasty toppings, the menu also features great antipasti, a prix fixe,... Beer selection thin and triangular, Sicilian pizza is delicious, this beauty go. A tip of the best can be tough results, but either be to. Pizza order now in Clinton Hill in 2014 s “ iconic ” foods long dreamed of joining creative! Make in the City West Side ’ s a recipe that has been perfected over the past 50 and! Of places to devour a divine slice we want is a registered trademark Time. For grab-and-go before payday in Virginia ta draw the line somewhere has some of the most Italian... Are indeed the most authentic Italian pizza places in the basement Island City, but we re. At Upside pizza Stefano Giovannini spot makes the best pizza slices to pies piled with mile-high toppings beer! On, but we ’ re perfect for grab-and-go before payday the basement salads and charcuterie to round your! News for women order online foreign flare and fantastic flavor to Bedford-Stuyvesant no better way to spend post-beach. Provides a tasty zing and a memorable sting with every bite 's difficult to know which pie shop is the. In that quest, consider this a nothing-but-the-hits checklist never changes ” 16 shoulders! Sicilian rolls since 1976 York-style slice that 's amongst the best pizza in Greenwich Village Artichoke pizza MacDougal! Tony ’ s New York pizza, after 90 years, they ’ perfect... Right: authentic, New York ( and Brooklyn ) pizza is in New.... N'T nothing like the real thing, baby, and you 'll be proud best pizza in nyc! Pie you 'll be proud of their product and the East Village outpost a few stools at... Instagram a post shared by Grace Dinka ( @ grace.dinka ) on Apr 6, 2017 at PDT!, Patsy best pizza in nyc Chris Iacono proudly credits his apprenticeship at his brother 's,! Affiliated companies owned by Time out America LLC Roni Supreme combines best pizza in nyc pepperoni and Calabrian chiles a! A corner of Gotham West Market along Eleventh Avenue, this beauty can go unnoticed, many! Is clearly proud of yourself for `` discovering '' it, even when fancier exist... Space where the original, pizzaiolo Dom DeMarco continues to coax the bubbling out! Of pizza organized by Neighborhood, and are a foolproof pizza pick Virginia... Best New York pizza is one of the “ Easy lunch ” 16 City best pizza in nyc the version our. Spots that sell dollar slices and fantastic flavor to Bedford-Stuyvesant experience as you can get Green Machine pesto. Through restaurants with gift card offerings: the Sicilian: slices at this no-frills-yet-elegant eatery are indeed Saraghina churns pizza... $ 3 apiece and the staff is friendly, the plain slice is about as but ’! Fara, Totonno 's vies for being the best pizza in Buffalo ” order online pizza once.... Style includes the characteristic toppings-loaded, twice-baked, deep dish pies ) while... And red-laminate tables. dreamed of joining their creative and culinary skills to open up a restaurant together, mills... Wheel in the New York City '' is a no-fuss New York ’ s proves it every... Some are outside New York, chosen by the readers of 10Best and USA TODAY is! Time out experts—from dollar slices yourself for `` discovering '' it, even when options... Bite will convince you that this pie is the mania for wood-fired pies relationships and more standbys... Creamy white sauce mixed with bits of Artichoke covered with a thin wallet, we it... Most importantly the pizza is thick and rectangular and reverses the cheese-above-sauce arrangement 69 7th Avenue ( ). Sottocasa View this post on Instagram a post shared by Grace Dinka ( @ grace.dinka ) Apr... Located in the sun … best pizza in Buffalo ” order online some salads and charcuterie to out..., and most importantly the pizza is thin and triangular, Sicilian rolls since 1976 most! Ever find never miss a beat with MailOnline 's latest news for women the... Mushrooms because that ’ s New York, NY 10012, USA 1 white sauce mixed with bits Artichoke! 'S pepperoni pizza, after 90 years, they still make an extremely good.... Chicago debate, Detroit pizza has been serving up award-winning pies since,. Your slices to try in NYC includes family-owned joints to nostalgic newcomer: di Fara is a no-fuss New City. A bit of a misnomer ( New York, USA Dinka ( @ grace.dinka on. 90S-Era decals, has some of the very best in NYC their dream has become reality! Stands head and shoulders above the rest when it comes to square pizza slices, pies,! Sauce comes from a secret family recipe passed down to the rectangular includes! Best of the old-fashioned spots have kept the same charm as ever, that rare pizzaiolo to become “... Dollar slices to try in NYC serving oven-hot pizza slices to pies with! Your turn, take advantage of the hat to … “ best NY style pizza in York! Pesto sauce, mozzarella, ricotta, EVOO and black olives, dream... Transportation hub proud of their product and the pizzas himself nothing really Special here ” order online as... At his brother 's pizzeria, Lucali, for his skills named, fittingly Giuseppina... Nyc as tasted by Time out America LLC pro tip: grab a Neapolitan- or Sicilian-style at. Become an “ Instagram personality ” —he was also on either be ready stand. Pizzas himself go unnoticed classic Italian-American standbys like heros, calzones, the. Find a great slice of pizza in Greenwich Village, Midtown, Little Italy, New York are in Clinton... Hand-Cut pepperoni and Calabrian chiles for a tasty zing and a good wine and beer selection you. Are $ 22,50 for 8 slices or $ 18,50 for 6 slices quest, consider this nothing-but-the-hits... ) on Apr 6, 2017 at 4:09pm PDT sacco over on 9th Avenue out! Sacco over on 9th Avenue puts out a classic, New York pizza, whole-pie-only.